+3 solo sound
This sounds like Lord Of Oats. You need to get your hands on the Antares Autotune. Good mixing overall, but the drums get a touch overbearing in places.
+3 real violin
You sound like a guy who can't sing too well, and is trying to work with what he's got. Not bad. This song would come off really well with a nice clean melody, though. The percussion would make a huge difference if it was more solidly locked in to some kind of beat.
This is catchy! Maybe a bit loud in the chorus, it sounds like it's clipping.
Berkely Social Scene
+3 overall mood
Everything but the vocals is great. See Appel Zeven's review.
+3 nice choice of chords
I dislike the vocal timbre, but at least you can carry a tune. I think I might like the vocals more if you put them in context of a much moodier song. Imagine Remy Shand covering Danzig with you singing.
+3 anthemic synth
-1 noisy stuff
I can't say I'm a fan of that bass, although it kinda fits right at the end. If you're gonna do that, you've got to give it room. The synth, on the other hand, was glorious.
+/- 2 being polite
This is the least potentially offensive song I've heard so far. I can't imagine not liking it, but it doesn't go out on a limb and do anything for me either.
+2 big ominous pipe organ
There's an instrument you don't hear everyday. Well, a sample of an instrument, at least. Kinda funny tossing the pan flute in there with it. Actually, the whole instrumentation is the only thing about this song that feels off.
Jon Eric & Friends
It sounds like you worked a lot harder on the sound of the rap vocals than the lead vocals, although both are performed very well. The upper register sounds great. This reminds me of something Moxy Fruvous would do.
+1 finding the loop button
I skipped ahead to get past the spoken intro. Shit, it's not just an intro.
Lordz Of The Fly
if lego made loops, you would have a lego song. I really dig the talkbox/vocoder thing though. I dig the guitar riff too, but wish it didn't just loop.
-1 weak beat
-2 not using the bell enough
The lack of instrumentation hurts this. The rapped vocals aren't bad, but they sound rookie in such a minimalistic track.
Old Man Grumpus
+2 interesting piano
Not that I feel every song needs drums & full instrumentation, but this would have been made better. The vocals aren't bad, but if they were more in key and had some harmonies, they would be great.
Paco Del Stinko
+2 having a ufo in the band
I don't know what to make of this. I kinda like it, but it makes me want to do some crack.
+3 meaning it
I don't know why, but I played this several times. I like the groove.
Sven, is that your new guitar? This needs a bit more of the gang vocal effect. The solo kicks ass.
+2 dirty synth guitar
Your vocals don't sound like you mean it at all. Neither do the drums.
+5 being that good
Vocals, playing, production... fantastic. Writing & lyrics... pretty good. The only bad thing I could say about this is that after listening to it, I can't remember how it goes. Is that a reflection on your songwriting, or my own attention span? Dunno.
+3 bringing a bit of the rock
Nice groove. It makes me want to twist. Definitely needs some backing vocals.
+3 not sounding like anything else here
-2 not cracking the 1:00 mark
This is good enough that it sucks when it's that short. Kinda reminds me of a Family Guy song. I want more. Longer, and with can-can singers.
+3 overall feel
-1 synth arp too loud
I think this is my personal favorite.
The Weakest Suit
-1 sing it like you mean it