As I, like many men I know, like to seek approval from attractive woman I've asked my friend for her thoughts on the fight. She went ahead and reviewed the whole fight. She is not a musician and does not know any of the technical babble that goes along with music production. I decided I'd share her review with you. She wrote this before reading anyone elses review, for purities sake.
----------------------------------------
Atari in the desert – Wow. I really liked the music, there was a hint of Cure in the first part of the vocals, and yet it also feels Justin Timberlake (yes I like JT), the quality and completeness of the song was very impressive, this was the first one I listened to which may have biased me overall – good voice, good production, good music, lyrics may not be indie-clever which tends to be more common in songfights, but it has that ‘I could hear this on the radio’ feel which isn’t a bad thing in my books (it actually reminded me of this
http://www.songfight.org/songpage.php?key=moon_shine winner who I loved so much it ended up on my MP3 player)
The Capitalist Youth – meh, it’s ok, not my taste alas, I kept waiting for some sort of change up in the music, the one around 1:22 was ok, retro-hippie song perhaps?
Eddiebangs – I think I like it, I’ll try it again when I’ve made it through the rest of the list, voice makes me think of Creed + 3 Doors down which I like – it held up to a second run listen, and third, and fourth, etc, catchy, the music is well put together, this is a ‘play it for your girlfriend for valentines’ (and get laid) song, - ties for second.
Futureboy – Not bad, makes me think of retro 80s, the beat makes me want to go out clubbing to the Dance Cave {local spot in our hood - Matt} for retronight, overtheshouldergallery thinks it’s They Might be Giant’s-esque (I don’t listen to them but it could be), the music almost overwhelms the lyrics, which I didn’t really get into until I’d listened to it a few times, but the chorus is catchy, where are my dancing shoes, I need to get out more :S - ties for second.
Cricketboycrew – I should like this but something’s not working for me, maybe changes flow too much with the chorus? It reminded me of 311 from the 50 First Dates movie, but somehow it’s not moving me enough.
JeffTravisHenderson – first impression is cute (like girls say cute), but the volume on the chorus seems off, I’ll listen to it again at the end see how it holds up, yeah didn’t make round 2 listening when compared to others, the chorus just isn’t sitting right I don’t know if I’m a fan of what feels like too many mixing of styles, but not bad and I like some of the lyrics, I’m just so undecided.
LMNOpotamus – rofl, awesome SlimShady impression, it’s actually not bad, just kinda funny, I know rap beats are repetitive, but it could have used a bit of a change up in the beat, I really wanted to turn up the volume to better hear the lyrics but the base was overwhelming which is a pity.
MCcrapalot – there’s something about 80s scifi tv shows in the music, I’m not a fan of megaphone rap though, not for me.
Pathetic octothrope – OMG it’s Rolf or Dr Teeth from the muppets! I can’t make out the lyrics enough to decide if their clever enough to make up for the kookyness, the volume on the vocals seems kinda off, but overall not my thing.
Pigpen – ack, so torn, so mixed, there’s a part of this song I like and a part I don’t, maybe if they had less weird effects? His voice is kinda sexy and I like the tune, but too much space vibe, it grows on me and I want to like it more, less UFOs and perhaps a bit more lyrics and it might just be stealth awesome.
Precarious Loaf – hard to review since I’ve heard the first version and liked it more in some ways (we can talk about that later), but it feels like maybe playing with too many new toys muddled it a bit, which is a pity cause I’m a big fan

{She hated the drums and guitar like everyone else does - Matt}
RoneRivendale – this intro beat was interesting, but then this whole spoken word thing really doesn’t do it for me.
Steve Durand – OMG awesome! This is total chair dancing music

alas the lounge esque voice doesn’t sound quite up to it all the time (like the bit starting at 1:28), but it’s cute and amusing, the music and lyrics are enjoyable, although I almost wish I could hear a Tom Waits gravelly voice version for comparison – this wins most amusing entry for me, it has an entertaining brilliance my kooky self cannot deny
StuJordan – wow, like the only boy-with-guitar song so far, blues is ok, the voice doesn’t feel quite ‘full’ enough for blue though, and I’m not sure about the chorus.
Uncle Gravy biscuts – cool it’s Sting and I like that, I want to dig up my old 10 summoners tales cd, very catchy, good production, the lyrics are good, it’s solid, cause I’m quirky I think this ties for my favourite with Atari.
Wages – second boy-with-guitar, hmm, umm, makes me think of some Eddie Veder angsty rock boy stuff, feels like there’s a blip around 1:21, it’s not quite working for me, a little too repetitive in the end.
The Weakest Suit – I think there’s this strange ‘singing in the shower’ effect that turns me off, it can really break a song for me.