Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

I beat Gyruss once.
Post Reply
User avatar
Spud
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 4770
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:25 am
Instruments: Bass, Keyboards, eHorn
Submitting as: Octothorpe
Location: Seattle
Contact:

Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Spud »

Discuss.

I want in, but with this sort of market fragmentation, I don't know where to start.
"I only listen to good music. And Octothorpe." - Marcus Kellis
Song Fight! The Rockening
User avatar
JonPorobil
Beat It
Posts: 5682
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 11:45 am
Instruments: Piano, Guitar, Harmonica, Mandolin, Accordion, Bass, lots of VSTs
Recording Method: Cubase 10.5
Submitting as: Jon Eric, Jon Porobil, others
Pronouns: He/Him
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by JonPorobil »

First things first:

Band Hero is actually part of the Guitar Hero series. Same manufacturer (Activision) and all, but they wanted to include "Band" in the name to emphasize that you can play with a large group of friends. Guitar Hero has had full-band capabilities for a while now, but consumers are pretty stupid. It's also got more "mainstream" acts, though I feel like both franchises stopped being about classic rock and heavy metal guitar jams a long time ago.

I think Rock Band (made by Harmonix) has the more ergonomically comfortable guitar/bass instruments. To the best of my knowledge, the drums and mics are practically interchangeable (in point of fact, they're literally interchangeable in that they're cross-compatible). I also think Rock Band's interface is more usable and its graphics look cleaner (I'm talking about the playing screens, not the characters and venues and stuff, because who cares about that? the people who aren't playing, that's who). However, Guitar Hero has more difficulty settings (5 to Rock Band's 4).

For those reasons, I've mainly played Rock Band. I think I tried Guitar Hero back when they were still on Guitar Hero 1, and I got frustrated because it's nothing like playing real guitar. I'm not familiar with the current song lists of both games, so if that's going to be your deciding factor, better check the song lists on their respective websites or Wikipedia.
"Warren Zevon would be proud." -Reve Mosquito

Stages, an album of about dealing with loss, anxiety, and grieving a difficult year, now available on Bandcamp and all streaming platforms! https://jonporobil.bandcamp.com/album/stages
User avatar
Märk
Jump
Posts: 2048
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 8:35 pm
Instruments: Guitar, bass
Recording Method: Presonus Audiobox 44VSL, Cubase
Submitting as: ROTR, svenmullet, I forget what else
Pronouns: master
Location: Canada

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Märk »

I'm totally gonna make a game called "Fleshlight Hero".
* this is not a disclaimer
User avatar
ujnhunter
Ice Cream Man
Posts: 1804
Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2008 1:09 pm
Instruments: Bass, Keyboards, Crummy Guitar & Animal Noises (especially Donkeys)
Recording Method: Reaper 5.9x, Tascam FireOne/Behringer UMC202HD/Avid Eleven Rack/Line 6 UX2, Win 7 PC / Win 10 Laptop
Submitting as: Cock, Chth*.*, D.A.H. (Der Alter Hahn)
Pronouns: His Infernal Majesty
Location: CT, USA
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by ujnhunter »

Rock Band 2 by Harmonix is the way to go... but even I'm getting tired of their shenanigans now too. The once fresh music game scene is now over populated with crap.
-Ujn Hunter
Photovoltaik - Free 6 Track EP - Song Fight! Liner Notes
Billy's Little Trip wrote:I must have this....in my mouth.....now.
User avatar
ken
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 3871
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 6:10 pm
Instruments: Guitar, bass, drums, keys
Recording Method: MOTU 828x, Cubase 10
Submitting as: Ken's Super Duper Band 'n Stuff
Pronouns: he/him
Location: oakland, ca
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by ken »

I'm in the same spot here since I got a Wii for Hanukkah! I really want Guitar Hero Aerosmith, and Rock Band, but the guitars aren't compatible. :( I'm thinking about buying the Beatle Rock Band for the instruments and the software only for the others.
Ken's Super Duper Band 'n Stuff - Berkeley Social Scene - Tiny Robots - Seamus Collective - Semolina Pilchards - Cutie Pies - Explino! - Bravo Bros. - 2 from 14 - and more!

i would just like to remind everyone that Ken eats kittens - blue lang
User avatar
Caravan Ray
bono
bono
Posts: 8647
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 1:51 pm
Instruments: Penis
Recording Method: Garageband
Submitting as: Caravan Ray,G.O.R.T.E.C,Lyricburglar,The Thugs from the Scallop Industry
Location: Toowoomba, Queensland
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Caravan Ray »

ken wrote:I'm in the same spot here since I got a Wii for Hanukkah!.
Yes - I am also thinking of buying myself a Wii for Hanukkah.

I just moved into my new house yesterday and we negotiated with the sellers that they leave behind the big-arsed TV they had attached to the wall. I was those Wii things in the shop and that looks like fun. You can get cricket where you actually use a cricket bat. That's cool.

So, I can also play the Beatles game on a Wii too? I will look into that later
User avatar
Spud
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 4770
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:25 am
Instruments: Bass, Keyboards, eHorn
Submitting as: Octothorpe
Location: Seattle
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Spud »

ken wrote:I really want Guitar Hero Aerosmith, and Rock Band, but the guitars aren't compatible.
Are you sure that's still true, Ken? Is is platform-specific? I was told by the guys at the Game Spot that the incompatibility has been fixed, so I bought a XBOX 360 wireless Less Paul Controller for Guitar Hero, and it worked fine with Rock Band. I preferred the Rock Band guitar, but this one worked, except for the lack of upper-fret buttons, which I am not sufficiently advanced to use anyway. I'm not sure they're even in play on bass. Maybe the problem is the other way around. Perhaps you can't use Rock Band guitars in Guitar Hero??? Anyone?
"I only listen to good music. And Octothorpe." - Marcus Kellis
Song Fight! The Rockening
User avatar
Spud
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 4770
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:25 am
Instruments: Bass, Keyboards, eHorn
Submitting as: Octothorpe
Location: Seattle
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Spud »

Generic wrote: ...consumers are pretty stupid.
Consumers aren't stupid, they just aren't informed. That's why I started this thread. I am surprised at you, Jon.
"I only listen to good music. And Octothorpe." - Marcus Kellis
Song Fight! The Rockening
User avatar
ken
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 3871
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 6:10 pm
Instruments: Guitar, bass, drums, keys
Recording Method: MOTU 828x, Cubase 10
Submitting as: Ken's Super Duper Band 'n Stuff
Pronouns: he/him
Location: oakland, ca
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by ken »

I don't think everything works together, only somethings:

http://www.rockband.com/compatibility

I see, you bought XBOX360, which seems to do better than Wii.
Ken's Super Duper Band 'n Stuff - Berkeley Social Scene - Tiny Robots - Seamus Collective - Semolina Pilchards - Cutie Pies - Explino! - Bravo Bros. - 2 from 14 - and more!

i would just like to remind everyone that Ken eats kittens - blue lang
User avatar
Spud
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 4770
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:25 am
Instruments: Bass, Keyboards, eHorn
Submitting as: Octothorpe
Location: Seattle
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Spud »

Well, I didn't buy one. I was running a Rock Band competition at the Mandalay Bay Hotel in Las Vegas for Microsoft, so they sent me one, temporarily, unfortunately, but that is where most of my experience comes from. That is a very useful chart and indeed, I see that there is a much higher degree of compatibility on the XBOX 360 than on the Wii.
"I only listen to good music. And Octothorpe." - Marcus Kellis
Song Fight! The Rockening
User avatar
irwin
Mean Street
Posts: 617
Joined: Mon Jan 22, 2007 10:09 pm
Instruments: insecurity
Recording Method: scotch
Submitting as: suckweasel, kasper, nutwalls
Location: Woodland, CA

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by irwin »

I have Guitar Hero 2 and 3, and Rock Band 2, and can echo the recommendation of Rock Band 2 as the best of the bunch.

The Guitar Hero franchise (I have not played World Tour/Band Hero) is more "video-gamey". It seems like there are passages that are intentionally difficult to play, rather than being musically necessary. I do like the Guitar Battle thing in Guitar Hero 3, but other than that, gameplay is very linear: you play from fixed sets in order. You can jump around within the setlist, but you don't get a new setlist until you finish they one you're on.

Rock Band feels much more musically natural to me, and is a much more satisfying playing experience. Gameplay is a lot less linear, which has both benefits and drawbacks. On one hand, you aren't locked in to playing the sets in order. The downside is you end up playing the same song many times in the course of career mode, which can be a bummer for those tracks you just can't stand.

Another area where Rock Band has a clear edge is in music selection: there's a much broader selection of styles. Again, I have not played Band Hero, so maybe that's better than the previous Guitar Hero titles in that regard.
"Ouch. I wonder if this guy sounds like this when he speaks." -- Puce
User avatar
Reist
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 3066
Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2006 2:26 pm
Instruments: Drums, Guitar
Recording Method: Yamaha AW1600, Reaper
Submitting as: Therman
Location: Calgary
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Reist »

I always thought guitar hero was a more satisfying multiplayer experience - mostly because I can't play the freaking rock band drums, no matter how hard I try.
User avatar
Niveous
Beat It
Posts: 7177
Joined: Mon Sep 27, 2004 6:45 am
Instruments: vocals, songwriting, guitar
Submitting as: Lucky Witch and the Righteous Ghost
Pronouns: He/him
Location: Staten Island, NY
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Niveous »

Rock Band is the better game. I agree with a lot that Irwin said, so I'll just add in this:

Harmonix made the original two Guitar Hero games and then moved on to Rock Band. They have a great understanding of how to meld music and gameplay. I've been playing Harmonix music games since 2001's FreQuency and they have consistently been fun. Factor in that Rock Band has a huge catalog of songs to play (over 1000 songs, with a new 6+ songs going on sale every week) and next year, Rock Band opens the Rock Band Network which will add a lot more songs including songfighters Brad Sucks ("Bad Attraction"!) and Beatnik Turtle. Rock Band is the way to go.

PS- With the two I have already mentioned, plus Frontalot, there are 3 Songfight bands in Rock Band. Let's go for more! Songfight makes some of the best music round. I think it deserves some more notice.
"I'd like to see 1984 redubbed with this in the soundtrack."- Furrypedro.
NUR EIN!
X-Tokyo
Lucky Witch and the Righteous Ghost
User avatar
JonPorobil
Beat It
Posts: 5682
Joined: Sat Sep 25, 2004 11:45 am
Instruments: Piano, Guitar, Harmonica, Mandolin, Accordion, Bass, lots of VSTs
Recording Method: Cubase 10.5
Submitting as: Jon Eric, Jon Porobil, others
Pronouns: He/Him
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by JonPorobil »

When did Beatnik Turtle enter Songfight?

[runs off and checks...]

Holy crap!

Though I dunno, I think they're in the same boat as MC Hawking. Yeah, they entered, but they had a fair amount of notoriety before they did so.
"Warren Zevon would be proud." -Reve Mosquito

Stages, an album of about dealing with loss, anxiety, and grieving a difficult year, now available on Bandcamp and all streaming platforms! https://jonporobil.bandcamp.com/album/stages
User avatar
Niveous
Beat It
Posts: 7177
Joined: Mon Sep 27, 2004 6:45 am
Instruments: vocals, songwriting, guitar
Submitting as: Lucky Witch and the Righteous Ghost
Pronouns: He/him
Location: Staten Island, NY
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Niveous »

Generic wrote:When did Beatnik Turtle enter Songfight?
[runs off and checks...]
Holy crap!
Though I dunno, I think they're in the same boat as MC Hawking. Yeah, they entered, but they had a fair amount of notoriety before they did so.
True. I only said that they are Songfighters. They have fought the song fight.
"I'd like to see 1984 redubbed with this in the soundtrack."- Furrypedro.
NUR EIN!
X-Tokyo
Lucky Witch and the Righteous Ghost
User avatar
Spud
Hot for Teacher
Posts: 4770
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:25 am
Instruments: Bass, Keyboards, eHorn
Submitting as: Octothorpe
Location: Seattle
Contact:

Re: Guitar Hero vs. Rock Band vs. Band Hero

Post by Spud »

Niveous wrote:Harmonix made the original two Guitar Hero games and then moved on to Rock Band.
Thanks for that tidbid, Niveous. I had forgotten about that, and it explains some of my confusion.
"I only listen to good music. And Octothorpe." - Marcus Kellis
Song Fight! The Rockening
Post Reply