mike - this is pretty cool. the voice needs to be mixed more exciting.
frankie - classic. i like the voices. this low guitar at 1:40 is oddly compelling. great background vox/foreground combos. i like the vox. did i mention the vox? i think they're especially good on this song. the "vishnu" ending is great.
caravan - good bass. i like the ethnicity feel. this may be the best one at bringing that element into the fight. not sure about it as a song, but it's definitely worth listening to.
zombie - did you know there's a jazz butcher song called "zombie love"? it's pretty strange. this is strange too. the vox are against each other, not with. music is interesting, but probably needs to change more.
charcoal - nice opening. hmm, this is pretty cool. however, i don't see any title significance. at 3:40 i'm wondering where it's going. good, but why is it called... that?
beefy - the intro stuff is ok. impressed that you sing that thing and it sounds all right. i dunno, the vox aren't doing it for me. the mix isn't that great.
meddling - another interesting instrumental that seems to have no relation to the title.
melvin - ah, the famous one. reminds me of something. hey, this is pretty good. sublime, maybe? dunno. anyway, i like it but i won't vote for it.
glenn - first time i heard this i was impressed at singing the title. good work! i love the backwards bit at the end after the fast vox.
ashok - i think there's some interesting stuff around 1:20. i think the quality of this stuff is definitely improving over time. so good work there. this should be around 3:30.
jimt - the beat is good. the vox lack intensity. 1:16 beat is great. weirdo.
mostly - good stuff! the piano coming in w/ vox is a great part. crazy solo, that's awesome.
bomb - where's that cut and paste... there we go: another interesting instrumental that seems to have no relation to the title.
max - "what is this crap" hmmmmm. did you not like your own song? i like how you seem to forget what you're singing later. but that intro part was too long.
phunt - it's rambly and unfocused. there are interesting ideas, but they don't work together. and the title significance; i know you say it's there, but if we can't hear it while listening it's not really a successful songfight. you're completely lost at 6:30. where did you go? nobody knows. i haven't had the chance to listen to the other parts so i can't comment on them.
favorites: mike, frankie, melvin, glenn, mostly
runnersup: caravan, zombie, charcoal, ashok, meddling, bomb
i'm gonna vote for frankie, and not because the name sounds like a cool word: phalanges.