The Song Fight Bulletin Board

Posted: **Fri Jan 21, 2011 5:30 am**

Impatient. Ours is now out there on t'internet, should you know where to look.

Posted: **Sat Jan 22, 2011 6:34 am**

mine was in last week...

Posted: **Sat Jan 22, 2011 12:07 pm**

Patience, everyone! Remember, volunteer effort... sorting through our spazzy naming conventions... etc.

I completely forgot about ID3 tags.

Posted: **Sat Jan 22, 2011 1:16 pm**

I didn't even know about id3 tags, after a quick look as to what they are, I will be putting them on all submissions from now on.

Posted: **Sun Jan 23, 2011 7:18 pm**

(I submitted as Executive, with a friend.)

Here are some very brief, stream-of-consciousness reviews.

1. Salt in the Wound: I don't know the original. But this would make an awesome fighting game theme.

2. The House Carpenter: I don't know the original. But G+G is always* a fun time.
*Not always. But here it is!

3. Divine: I requested this. When I heard the start, I was concerned it would be overly twee, but... wow. You nailed it.

4. Not If You Were The Last Junkie On Earth: I played along with this on my slide whistle. Conclusion: This cover needs some slide whistle. I kid, I kid. Very well-done.

5. Stella: I don't know the original. This rocks, but I wonder if I need to contextualize it with the original.

At this point I got distracted. I'll try to get back for more feedback later.

Posted: **Sun Jan 23, 2011 7:30 pm**

I.e. the gom site has been updated. Yay! I can't wait to hear stuff. I'm glad Chris Cogott chose the Brodeur song as I can imagine that working quite well.

Posted: **Sun Jan 23, 2011 7:41 pm**

Oh cool. Time for some new listening.

Here's a quick link to this years Gift of Music. http://www.soultreerecords.com/GOM/2010.html

Posted: **Sun Jan 23, 2011 9:26 pm**

Posted: **Mon Jan 24, 2011 12:49 am**

And anyway just copy-pasting that won't work due to the ellipsises.

I'm very very busy right now so I'm only listening to Chris Cogott's cover of The Remains of a Heart. It is pretty great! I've also posted about GOM to Twitter in a way which will hopefully cause Brodeur to listen to it, so maybe he'll like it too. :)

Posted: **Mon Jan 24, 2011 4:32 pm**

Hmm.. I didn't see the Boffo Yux Dudes song up there, so I resent it. Might have gotten lost in the either or something. There's gotta be a Banana Phone up there!

Tom

Posted: **Mon Jan 24, 2011 11:52 pm**

BoffoYux wrote:Hmm.. I didn't see the Boffo Yux Dudes song up there, so I resent it. Might have gotten lost in the either or something. There's gotta be a Banana Phone up there!

Tom

I see it now, but it's hidden behind a pop up at the bottom.

Posted: **Mon Jan 24, 2011 11:57 pm**

I'm pretty grateful that Eddiebangs runs this thing and does all the hosting and website stuff and so on, but is there any chance that we could get the data in a way that's easier to fix the tags on? The HTML is pretty nasty and hard to parse (and it looks like it's made by a word processor or something). A simple spreadsheet or CSV or something would be a lot easier to work with.

If something doesn't already exist it's not a huge deal and I guess I could just do something myself with HTML::Parser or Greasemonkey or something, but I really like having my ID3 tags consistent in my file collection, since that makes iTunes a lot happier.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 5:44 am**

Just finished listening to everything, well done everyone. This was my first time following this project, and it has officially made me a fan. Looking forward to next year already.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 8:44 am**

fluffy wrote:I'm pretty grateful that Eddiebangs runs this thing and does all the hosting and website stuff and so on, but is there any chance that we could get the data in a way that's easier to fix the tags on? The HTML is pretty nasty and hard to parse (and it looks like it's made by a word processor or something). A simple spreadsheet or CSV or something would be a lot easier to work with.

If something doesn't already exist it's not a huge deal and I guess I could just do something myself with HTML::Parser or Greasemonkey or something, but I really like having my ID3 tags consistent in my file collection, since that makes iTunes a lot happier.

Got a PM from Eddiebangs that says he will be updating the pages, giving them a more pro, cleaner look. It's all a part of his plans to make it a bigger part of his label, Soul Tree Records, as the label grows.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 9:54 am**

wow... SO GOOD! every single song was out of this world good. i dont know over half the originals and am having a great time listening, comparing, contrasting. an extra special big thanks to the tedward nixon experience for rocking out a killer version of a personal favorite. i am working up some rave reviews in my head, and will post them all at a later date
, i.e. when i have time to go through them all again. so happy to be allowed to be part of this, and excited to be a pert in the future.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 10:50 am**

I'd like to thank Tomski for his rendition of Solo Flights by Eagles of Death Metal. It's funny that this is the second year in a row that my gifter did the cover with a ukulele. J$ last year, and AWESOME! What are the chances? But I must say, this is the best ukulele song about masturbation I've ever heard and done perfectly awesome!

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 12:29 pm**

Billy's Little Trip wrote:I see it now, but it's hidden behind a pop up at the bottom.

In Firefox, the banner at the bottom of the page is obstructing the lower part of the grid, making the links for the last couple of entries inaccessible.

It looks fine in IE and in the iPhone browser.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 12:40 pm**

Albatross wrote:
Billy's Little Trip wrote:I see it now, but it's hidden behind a pop up at the bottom.
In Firefox, the banner at the bottom of the page is obstructing the lower part of the grid, making the links for the last couple of entries inaccessible.

It looks fine in IE and in the iPhone browser.

Well, I heard yours via Anti-m's link above. Awesome by the way. I like what you did there. You rocked it!

Yeah, I use FF. I clicked to block pop ups, but it still thought there was a pop up there and I couldn't click the last two songs. I'll open it in IE. Thanks.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 5:17 pm**

BoffoYux wrote:I didn't see the Boffo Yux Dudes song up there, so I resent it.

Don't resent your song for being a late-bloomer! That's overly harsh.

Posted: **Tue Jan 25, 2011 9:52 pm**

Tuuur - Thanks for the gift. I am absolutely loving the psychedelic guitar solo.

BBABM wrote: an extra special big thanks to the tedward nixon experience for rocking out a killer version of a personal favorite.

Thanks. Glad you liked it!

Posted: **Wed Jan 26, 2011 1:22 am**

Recovering from flu I just got to see the songs posted now...
And now thanks in public to fluffy for an excellent Beck cover.
I immediately made it into my default ringtone (and yes, that is meant as a compliment!

)
And glad you liked my rendition inevitableguy!

Posted: **Wed Jan 26, 2011 3:54 am**

Another year. Another shafting

The Song Fight Bulletin Board

The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music

Re: The 8th Annual Gift of Music