The Song Fight Bulletin Board

Oh yeah? Well, here's how I see it:

1. Frankie Big Face
2-5,999,999,999. Everyone Else in the World
6,000,000,000. Caravan Ray

What do you think of that!!?!

Yeah, crap, dude. And you were going to give me that prize at songfight live except that I can't hold my liquor? I'll acknowledge neither of my songs so far have that same INTENSE ROCK FURY OF ROCK, but why you gotta break my balls all the time, son?

Wow people! Nur vier und zwanzig!

This may be the new best collection of 24 songs I've heard on SongFight. I have no idea which way the judges will go.

If were up to me Thank Glennny for the Frisbee would make the cut, but I have no idea where to rank us. Otherwise here's my top 19

1. Paco Del Stinko- I can't believe you made me love a song about dancing.

2. BL/BR
2. Frankie Big Face- This makes me want to go listen to Sci-Fi Lullibies. Suede fan?
2. The Bovine Recyclery

5. BK
5. Jim Tyrell
5. Merisan
5. Puce
5. Ross Durand
5. Steve Durand

11. Sp00n
11. Tex
11. The BeWells

14. Abomominous
14. Jolly Roger
14. Wreckdom

17. BLT

18. Calfborg
18. Rabid Garfunkel

Tough job to cut any of these, unfortunately I'd let go of:

21. MK- Started off great, but then wimped out with the "unique New York" bit. The riff is great, very Modest Mouse.

21. Lostman- Not a bad song, tough crowd. Seems a little phoned in. I don't like the lead guitar playing.

21. Ice 9- Again, not bad, competition is high. The melody is a little weak to me. Music is not interesting enough to save it.

21. Sausage Boy- This is the one song I'm actually not really in to.

I like the other half of TGFTF better. He always likes my songs

My new favorite word- Zwanzig. It sounds like a collaboration between Billy Corgan and Glen Danzig.

I'll give you a better one:

Zugzwang

It's German of course, and there's no English equivalent. Basically it's a chess term that means "the compulsion to move".



Kill Me Sarah wrote:

I like the other half of TGFTF better.

Me too, he writes the great songs with the great lyrics, I just scratch my chin and say "this needs Mandolin!"

glennny wrote:
Me too, he writes the great songs with the great lyrics, I just scratch my chin and say "this needs Mandolin!"

Whatever. You guys go together like Timberlake and Timbaland!

I think (as many apparently do) that we deserve at least one more week. There are three songs in this fight I can't even listen to more than once and a couple more that, while well done, aren't all that interesting. There are a lot of very talented musicians here and I think sometimes a production-perfect mediocre song immediately is liked over a poorly produced gem. I would not have Kellis anywhere near bottom five in this one. There were a couple that sparkled with squeaky clean production and technically well played instruments that maybe weren't the most inventive "songs".

I find it very hard to imagine I would survive round Two, if I were to make it that far, but I personally think we were good enough to pass this one.

glennny wrote: Zugzwang
It's German of course, and there's no English equivalent. Basically it's a chess term that means "the compulsion to move".

Ah, chess terms. Love 'em. My son just started playing (yes the 7 year old has a desire to play chess everyday) and I love the terminology. Zugzwang. Alekhine's Gun. Zwischenzug. Desperado pieces. Greek Gift Sacrifice. X-Ray Attack! Only prowrestling has a better set of crazy manuever names.

While we're off-topic: I play at http://www.gameknot.com. If you go there and sign up, my handle is citizensix. Let's play chess.

Back on topic, sort of: There's at least a dozen songs in this fight that deserve to be in the top five. I thought that the alliteration requirement was going to produce a lot of really grating lyrics (I tried to make the instnaces of this as understated as I could in my own submission), but the results aren't so bad, by and large. Nice work, gang.

glennny wrote:I'll give you a better one:

Zugzwang

It's German of course, and there's no English equivalent. Basically it's a chess term that means "the compulsion to move".

You know this and still you named your band Zipline?

Ken

jimtyrrell wrote:I thought that the alliteration requirement was going to produce a lot of really grating lyrics.

Funny that you say that. I had so many alliterations on my first pass, that as I listened to it through my headphones, I was rolling my eyes because it was so hokey and killed my double meaning words/story. So I left my "important" story words, and changed the phrasing until it had my original meaning. I made this decision the day before the due time, so basically I rerecord the main vocals when I should have been working on production and such.

By the way Jim, you really took me by surprise this week. You rocked your shiz! I was repeating it last night. Cool song and it honestly sounds like part one of my story this week if it was ever made into a movie, lol. Also, there are several that could be part 3, 4, and so on. We could make a movie about Crystal Cocaine that goes into the sister hood, then God speaks to her and tells her that she must go from the pew to the pole to wow the world with her beautiful biblical breasts!
But I'll have to put my foot down that the part of Crystal Cocaine is played by Reese Witherspoon and God is played by Bill Clinton.
.....oh, and Jay and Silent Bob have to be in there somewhere with a cameo from Jack Black and Kyle.

Funny, I still have no idea if there's enough alliteration in my entry. I think so, but my opinion doesn't count for much there The wonderful bitch of the challenge was making it not stand out like a sore tooth. For the most part, yeah, we all hit that mark pretty well.

±24.5 hours to the next round. And seeing if my consistent low-end-of-the-scale rating (except you, Tex :-* ) by my fellow fighters is a harbinger of the next round's fun.

Jim Tyrell & WreckdoM, y'all are both breaths of fresh air. Though Albatross is rolling in 'da Stink, this round.

Okay guys, I'm amazed... also I hate the idea of saying who I'd keep and who I'd lose, that's really harsh y'know, 'cause in regular songfights you can slate a guy, but pretty much know he'll be back next week, in this if you say hey that songs not as good as the other songs then the judging comes along and maybe just maybe you've got it kinda right, then shit, dude's not back next week, ... doh! that's the whole point!!

Seriously...
----------------------------------------
I'd definately keep the following:
Tex Beaumont and the Dirty Hearts
Paco del Stinko
Mersian
The Bovine Recyclery
Billy's Little Trip
Balance Lost/Balance Regained
----------------------------------------
Probably would also keep:
Rabid Garfunkel
Calfborg
Thank Glenny for the Frisbee
Jim Tyrrell
Abominominous
Frankie Big Face
Steve Durand
Puce
Ross Durand
Brian Kandel
----------------------------------------
The Rest need to fight it out in a naked gory blood fest!
Mr. Lostman and the ElephantU
Cynthia Size and the @eclectic spOOns
Wreckdom
The BeWells
Sausage Boy
Jolly Roger
Marcus Kellis
Ice 9
------------------------------------------

Yeah, I've been not wanting to say who I would cast out either. Here's my short "definitely in" list. This why I'm not singling out just a few people I didn't like, because I liked 88% of the songs this week.

Top Five*

The Bovine Recyclery
Billy's Little Trip
Thank Glennny for the Frisbee
Puce
Marcus Kellis

*In no particular order

glennny wrote: 2. Frankie Big Face- This makes me want to go listen to Sci-Fi Lullibies.

Do it! and skip to My Dark Star.
"She will come from IndiaAAAa"

Kill Me Sarah wrote: Top Five*

The Bovine Recyclery
Billy's Little Trip
Thank Glennny for the Frisbee
Puce
Marcus Kellis

*In no particular order

AWESOME, we made somebody's top 5
thanks 9-er

Billy's Little Trip wrote:
Once again, an AWESOME set of songs.

erin. wrote:
Wow! People are really stepping up. I don't envy the judges this round, there are going to be some tough decisions to make. There is some enviable musicianship at hand.


Niveous wrote:
Really? Hmmm...



Ok, so what I mean is that compared to last week, there seems to be alot more effort in the writing/lyrical sense...maybe less in the execution (production). I think people really took the challenge into consideration before they came up with music for the song.
Just an observation.
Also...am I the the first and only female in this fight?

erin. wrote: Also...am I the the first and only female in this fight?

I didn't know you were female. The gorilla-robot pic is pretty androgynous.

I'm assuming however that you are the female from Merisan? Yes, you are the only female Nur Einer this year. Though if you look around the boards you'll find there aren't many lady Song Fighters period.

That's no gorrilla, that's robot-bigfoot. ( robot-sasquatch if you prefer).
I am Erin of Merisan, and the only female in this fight.
I feel a little bit like I should try hard to stay in just to represent my fellow lady Songfighters...not that I'm getting any support from them so far.....(Ahem)...but really, I'm in it for my own love of Songfight!
And... Lunkhead made me do it.

Bjam was in the first Nur Ein. Cynthia is in this one, and I believe in her, dammit.

I'm glad Merisan is in. More Lunkhead and Erin! Your performance of Violet at SF05 in Boston was gorgeous. And Loyalty Day's "Crossroads" is still a favorite of mine.

erin. wrote: I feel a little bit like I should try hard to stay in just to represent my fellow lady Songfighters...not that I'm getting any support from them so far

I think you'll do well. Being a lady with a decent set of pipes goes a long way around here. It's a refreshing sound we don't hear all that often in the regular fights

Last week you had a Frente! vibe going. This week's song almost has a Bangles feel to it. I love both by the way.

Incidentally, I swear Tex's song last week was ripping off Bangles' "Different Light".

P.S. Total respect goes out to those songfighters who are also competing in the weekly fights as well as taking part in this Nur Ein Challenge.

Erin, your voice is superb, I've been sold both weeks so far, I have Mersian down as a cert for qualification.