The Song Fight Bulletin Board

I thought the Royal Tennenbaums sucked

Loved The Life Aquatic though

Wow. It's unfortunate that JB is going to kill you, Hoblit. It's been nice knowing you.

I had my doubts about Life Aquatic, but I loved it, and continue to love it. It's not quite a Rushmore (favorite movie ever) or Royal Tenenbaums, but it's close enough. I think your feelings about it can be decided on how you feel about that scene at the end with the jaguar shark, and everyone's hands on Bill. If you thought it was moving and a fitting emotional climax, you probably like the movie. If you laughed and rolled your eyes (like a lot of people I know), you probably never bought into the film, and are likely a hater. Me? A

I also gave it a B. It was entertaining, but I think the central performances (Bill Murray and Anjelica Huston) were so detached and unemotional that it made it hard for me to give a crap about what happened to them. They were deliberately like that, I suppose, but that just didn't work for me. It looked amazing, of course, and the music was great, and I liked all the other characters (especially Owen Wilson, Jeff Goldblum, and Willem Dafoe).

Overall I liked it, but it just didn't have "the heart" (to use a tired cheesy phrase) that Royal Tenenbaums or even Rushmore had. Royal Tenenbaums is one of my all time favorites. Every character in that movie is fleshed out really well and the acting is great. Everybody has a nice story arc. It just seemed a lot better conceived.

raisedbywolves wrote: I think your feelings about it can be decided on how you feel about that scene at the end with the jaguar shark, and everyone's hands on Bill.

uh, yeah...didn't make it that far...had better things to do with my time and decided not to waste any more of my life on that particular 'film'.

raisedbywolves wrote: Wow. It's unfortunate that JB is going to kill you, Hoblit. It's been nice knowing you.

eh, I can take im'

Now you're being deliberately inflammatory...

Oh man, that bit where they're all walking along the pier trying to look like reservoir dogs or something made me laugh so hard. and conceptually it felt like they were trying to make the worst soundtrack ever and yet it manages to top the Rushmore soundtrack which I thought was brilliant. Portuguese Bowie and Atari electro, they should've got an award for that

An utterly fantastic movie. It was like 'what would Tintin be like if he grew up' or 'what would life be like if it was made in the image of those vaguely educational comics from the 50s with cut-away views of submarines'.

Very enjoyable. Wistful, which is a good thing in movies. I give it an A-

a bebop a rebop wrote:Now you're being deliberately inflammatory...

yeah, isn't that the nature of movie critic threads?

Actually, thats how I felt. I didn't like it at all and was mad that even spent an hour and $3 on it. If I was a really angry guy...I would have thrown my beer or something

Man, 3 bucks for a movie? Damn you, New York City, cheating me out of my rightfully-earned cheap movies!

The scene wherein Steve takes the ship back with the Stooges blaring gets my heartbeat going faster every time. It's so hilarious and badass. I love this movie.

I'm with Hoblit on this one.

I love his other movies... was very disappointed by this one.

Then again, I see lots of movies, and hate most of 'em. I'm very tough on movies, for some reason.

And, yes, hallelujah for the 3$ "brew and views" of Stumptown! Beer numbs the pain!

WeaselSlayer wrote:The scene wherein Steve takes the ship back with the Stooges blaring gets my heartbeat going faster every time. It's so hilarious and badass. I love this movie.

Steve kicked the shit out of those pirates.

they're all bill murray movies, hoblit.

would you prefer the rusty steak knife or the rusty garden hoe?