And remember, the final vote comes from judges AND all the fallen competitors.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Sun Jun 30, 2024 9:00 pm
by Lunkhead
So glad to finally be done. It's been a long 8 weeks! Cheers to the judges and all the contestants, and to Pete, who I'm sure will be a very worthy competitor in the finals.
Nur Ein!
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Sun Jun 30, 2024 10:25 pm
by furrypedro
Hear hear. I'm looking forward to a well earned rest.
I'm delighted to have made the final and compete against such a talented and esteemed opponent. Good luck!
And thanks to the judges for sacrificing your time so this could happen!
Nur Ein!
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Sun Jun 30, 2024 10:38 pm
by Spintown
Good luck to you both. I look forward to hearing your songs at the LP, hope to see you there.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Mon Jul 01, 2024 9:34 am
by WreckdoMelle
THESE ARE AWESOME!!!! How very exciting, great work y’all.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Mon Jul 01, 2024 10:25 am
by BoffoYux
I'm live with the finals tonight - sliding the start to 10pm, EST because of work.
Balance Lost - love the arpeggios. That intro is killer. And the part in between the verses is great too. Vocals sound good, i find this lyrical topic interesting - it’s on the face a bad relationship, but the narrator can still see the good in it? At first i was a little put off by the cadence, but it grew on me throughout the song. Ending is excellent.
Moss Palace - Real nice intro here too. Love the synth there. The synths. Yes. i like your chorus better. Vocals sound real good. There’s a little bit of muffly character to this mix… maybe it could be brighter. This would be fun to remix. But i love those synths. Did i mention the synths?
Brown Word and the Big Whine - that sound in the beginning is cool. I want more of that. Delusions of morality is good. Is that from something? Alien? The detonation sounds like that. Anyway. I like “i’m humaning the best i can” too.
Spintown & Company - oh yeah i hear the warrant. “Been got” is a little awkward. I find some of the rhymes here to be a little pat. But clipped/ill-equipped is cool. I dig the solo. What’s a rotating prayer? Vocals are definitely in style. Fun one.
Now as for final rankings. I have not been sharing them but i will here. I really liked both of the finalist songs, but i feel like moss palace wins out by half a point. Great work both of you.
Spintown & Company - oh yeah i hear the warrant. “Been got” is a little awkward. I find some of the rhymes here to be a little pat. But clipped/ill-equipped is cool. I dig the solo. What’s a rotating prayer? Vocals are definitely in style. Fun one.
Thanks once again for the review. Well, this song is about me playing Bed Wars. I use a punch bow as my main weapon & a lot of the song is someone trying to counter it in various ways with different items. Hypixel Network introduced rotating items to the game a couple years ago. So each week there are 2 new items you can buy in the in game shop. Rotating prayer is referencing that. Someone running out of ideas, so they check the rotational items hoping it's something that'll help them.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Wed Jul 03, 2024 6:29 pm
by Lunkhead
OMG!!! I can't believe it. Good game, Pete, it was so close it could have gone either way. Thanks again to Niv and the other judges and everybody.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Wed Jul 03, 2024 6:45 pm
by furrypedro
Congratulations Moss Palace!
well played.
I can't lie, it's disappointing to come so close, but hey at least this way I don't have to judge next year!
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Wed Jul 03, 2024 6:51 pm
by Spintown
Congrats to Moss Palace!
Also, great work to Balance Lost, you made it interesting for sure. Couldn't get much closer.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Wed Jul 03, 2024 11:33 pm
by frankie big face
Greetings from Deutschland! (When Niveous says Tchüss…)
Congrats to Moss Palace on a well-deserved win!
And kudos to Balance Lost for consistently strong work throughout the competition.
This was good fun. Thanks, Niveous!
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2024 6:54 am
by frankie big face
Also wanted to say a special thanks to Heuristics for being the only judge to post reviews every round, even after taking a few lumps from grumpy contestants. Thanks Bill!
Also wanted to say a special thanks to Heuristics for being the only judge to post reviews every round, even after taking a few lumps from grumpy contestants. Thanks Bill!
+1 to that.
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2024 9:59 am
by WreckdoMelle
Awesome job Moss Palace! And Balance Lost! It was a tossup for me, I had to listen a couple times.
Thanks to Niveous and the judges, all the players, folks who reviewed or otherwise participated, Tommy hosting the listening parties, it's been really fun. Heard a lot of great work.
I'll say it was wise to end before the 4th, getting noisy around here. Be safe everyone! Tschuss bis spater!
Re: Nur Ein XIX Final Round - "Parting Shot"
Posted: Fri Jul 05, 2024 11:38 am
by HeuristicsInc
You're welcome! Even as some of the grumpy contestants
I figure I need to write them anyway so I can do tie-breakers after the initial ratings... so I might as well post my thoughts.