jack shite wrote:
because when someone lazily proclaims "well this whole fight pretty much sucks but i'm not gonna really tell you why", i'll be thinking "why did we really need to know this?"
Okay, you want my didn't-like-much reviews, you got them.
all this crap is my opinion. i feel like i need to say that here because my opinion is not high on these songs, for the most part.
wreckdom - i like how this is more like a song. but the voice doesn't really fit the music. "you have dishonored me" and "the iron fists of wreckdom" are good.
casio choir - the repeating motif sounds a bit too much like the one from trio's "da da da." seems ripped off. enjoyable tho.
luke - the beginning is stumbling all over the shop, breaking things. then it changes. i don't like the vocals at all. the synth parts are out of time. the drums are pretty good. i like the fake handclaps, but then the synths and yelling come in again. yuk.
wounded - nice opening, good echo. i like the layered percussions. the static noise is out of time and too loud. what does this have to do with ninjas or gangs?
pileus - this is ok. the vocals are a bit expressionless. think this section with samples is going on a bit long. the drums and bass are nice. maybe you need a good chorus in here. not too excited about the lyrics. at 4:30 i'm thinking "how much longer is this?" but i don't hate it. that "yahh" noise is cool.
boltoph - this is pretty cool. when you sing "our ninja gang" it sounds not so good, rerecord that part. i like the drums, maybe a touch too loud. good guitars. this is definitely the best song so far. tho this part around 2:40, time-wise, doesn't work as well as the rest did.
c hack - your lyrics are funny. at first i wasn't sure about this song, but now i like it a lot on the second listen. "they had 20 swords, gun, arrows" is good stuff. i don't follow where the "i would do anything" comes from, but that's ok.
sforch - timing seems kind of off, so the elements don't play that well together, but i like all of them separately.
consume - sounds amateurish. i think with a voice like this you need to do something weird with the vox. also, the lyrics aren't all that. "ninjas got wangs"? sheesh. time to eat some oven fries and watch simpsons.
sleazy - this is pretty neat, but is missing some "je ne sais quios" or however you spell that. i just don't feel like the parts meld that well.
3hole - cute. "disgust us/justice" is funny. cute, but a bit short.
oedipus - this part at 1:20 is good. interesting use of samples. i think the "chorus" part is stronger than the "not chorus" part. at 4:21 the instrumental break is very good.
butter - great music. the lyrics aren't up to snuff, though. "seepin/weepin/kick your ass" is pretty contrived.
code - starting right off with lyrics i hate to go along with the terrible flow. yes, this was one of the ones i stopped listening to before it ended. ok, i'll do it again. this is just offensive in many ways. watch me hit "delete."
caravan - the music is pretty neat. weird silly person. i kind of like it, but then again i think it's just too silly. i will conclude with "silly but pretty good."
fronts - not the best frontalittle. you rhymed the wang too, huh. wait, i recognize that guitar sample. which songfight was that from? good karate kid sample.
neil - too much repetition on the chorus. not too enamored of the lyrics, but this is ok. "in the forest" doesn't work well rhythmically. this is ok. oops i said it twice so it must be true.
1: boltoph, c hack, oedipus
2: wreckdom, casio, wounded, pileus, sforch, sleazy, 3hole, butter, caravan, fronts, neil
999999999: code
the songs that make me happy are the 3 1 levels. my vote for Best Song goes to c hack.
-bill