I've given it a lot of thought, and my final top four are: 4) Melvin - so much good stuff there, not quite as catchy or memorable as the others 3) Tam Lin - if only it built up a little more, added electric guitar, a beat, or something 2) Ross Durand - if only it was a little creepier 1) The Hell Ye...

URBANmail - I like the beat, I like the rapping style, I don't like the lyrics. Good effort, but not my thing.

Much thanks for the feedback, constructive or otherwise. It's at least good to know what formulas work, and which ones don't. Antisoc - My track, but I'm still going to review it as if I were another person. Drums could be changed up a little more. Vocals are a little off in places. Perhaps a little...

Kill Me Sarah: Ixnay on the ogrammedpray umdrays, svp. Since this was comment seemed to apply to a lot of people for you in this fight, may I ask what you would have us do instead? Those of us without actual drums? Is your problem that they are not real drums, or just that they don't sound like rea...

rdurand wrote:It doesn't help that some of what appear to be first-ever songs win.

It's both inspiring and depressing at the same time.

I'm in as my nerdcore project Antisoc

http://antisocial.softcheese.net

Truth and Regret - I'm not usually a fan of autotuning vox but it works here... just wish you would've dropped the auto-tune during the distorted vocals. Is that what "autotune" sounds like? My god, the things I'd read about it make me think it was a much more subtle effect than that, lik...

No Really, Not Like That, Nothing Day I wonder if one could use all three of these in a chorus and enter one song in all three categories Smile Has anyone ever tried that? Hmm... What if I used all three in a chorus, then waited till the last second to enter my song in, and pick the most deserted f...

The Stink by Truth and Regret ----------------------- saturday you came over and left your tact right by the door if a fight was what you wanted you got that and so much more chorus ------ settle down, lets be reasonable calm yourself, and blow into a bag you are more irrational than you think when ...

I'm going Queens of the Stone Age style for "The Stink"

I have stuff to study for, so I can't deal with it now, but I'll put my reviews up this weekend. Looks like another lost fight for me

Oversleeping by Truth and Regret (Mark Ridlen) (there have been some changes, but this is pretty close) fingers smash the snooze alarm twenty separate times roll over and go back to my special place pre chorus I try to get back to dreaming aah but it's getting harder and harder to sleep chorus But t...

I'm in for oversleeping... hope that isn't the big fight this week

Ended up voting for Tim Hinkle. I hope it wasn't already tallied.

By the way... y'all need to learn to tag your mp3s before sending them in. It would make it so much easier on me.

I'm gonna be completely honest here. I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings. I hope that you will be as brutally honest with me. I'm not trying to be a bad guy, but any compliments you recieve will be well deserved. I haven't reached a vote conclusion yet, but here are the reviews: great list (the conten...

I could have chosen S___ Rock, but noooooo, I had to choose the fight with everyone and their dog on it...

I Like to Pretend by Truth and Regret ----------------------- I tell myself the same lie day after day over and over again until I forget my pain ... and I'm beginning to believe myself and believe my own lies and see the world through darkened eyes chorus ------ I like to pretend that I am wanted i...

I'm in for "I Like to Pretend" ...and it's a little darker than my usual style

Jim Fallope and his Fallopian Dudes: This song might have been a contender if there wasn't that weird vocal effect on your voice. Give it much much less of the strange effects next time. It seems like you can sing, so there's no point in hiding behind strange effects that ruin the mood of the song....

Truth+regret:**1/2 sounds like a dance song for people who don't like to dance ( i mean that in the nicest of ways really). The vocals are a little loud in the mix for my tastes. To test this i turned the volume way down, and when i couldn't even make out the music the vocals where still pretty aud...

OK, here goes... never done the detailed reviews before... please don't shoot me. If you have any further questions regarding this, let me know, I would be happy to discuss in detail how your song sucked (constructively, of course) --------------------------------------------------------------------...